When Did We Start Expecting the Worst From Each Other?

On the stories we tell about people, the power of our words, and the extraordinary difference a little kindness can make.

The night before my oldest daughter turned thirteen, she told me something that broke my heart. She didn’t want to become a teenager. She wanted time to stop. At first, I assumed she was nervous about growing up, leaving childhood behind, or facing the changes that come with adolescence. But that wasn’t it. She was worried about what people would think of her once she became a teenager.

She had noticed the way adults say the word teenager. The eye rolls, exaggerated sighs, and knowing smiles. She had heard comedians make teenagers the punchline of jokes and listened as other parents warned Adam and me about what was coming. Three daughters? Just wait until they’re teenagers! As though our household was approaching some inevitable disaster. For years, she’d been absorbing the message that becoming a teenager meant becoming difficult, moody, dramatic, and impossible to understand. She hadn’t even turned thirteen, and already she was worried about being judged for something she hadn’t done.

I found that incredibly sad. I happen to think adolescence is one of life’s most extraordinary chapters. You’re discovering who you are, developing your own opinions, questioning what you’ve always accepted, and beginning to understand the world through your own eyes. There is so much to celebrate about that. Yet here was my daughter, standing at the beginning of it all, wishing she could stay exactly where she was.

I’ve thought about that conversation repeatedly this week, perhaps because life has given me plenty of opportunities to examine my own expectations. It’s been quite a week. A thirteenth birthday, Halloween, a national election, the clocks changing, autumn settling into North Carolina, and foot surgery that brought my usual pace of life to an abrupt halt. Suddenly, the person accustomed to moving, working, organizing, and taking care of everyone else was the person who needed taking care of.

Before surgery, I had a lovely picture of how things would unfold. My three daughters would recognize that Mom was out of commission and rise beautifully to the occasion. Meals would be prepared, dishes washed, laundry done, and everyone would work together with a newfound appreciation for everything that normally happens behind the scenes. Well, you can probably imagine how that went. The girls helped, but they were also exhausted. They had school, activities, homework, and busy lives that didn’t magically stop because mine had. When things weren’t getting done the way I’d imagined, I became irritated.

Meanwhile, Adam was trying to work, earn money, manage the children’s schedules, care for me, and keep our household functioning. He had expectations of himself that were probably even greater than those I’d placed on everyone else. And there I was, frustrated because reality wasn’t following the script I’d written. I’d become so focused on what I needed that I’d temporarily lost sight of what everyone else was carrying. The people I loved hadn’t failed me. They were tired, overwhelmed, and adjusting, just as I was.

It made me wonder how often we do this, even with the people we know best. How often do we judge people before we know them? And perhaps more importantly, what happens when they begin believing our judgments?

We do it so casually. Teenagers are difficult. Older people are stubborn. Young adults are entitled. People from another generation don’t understand. We hear someone’s profession, religion, political affiliation, or where they grew up, and suddenly we think we know something important about their character.

This election week offered a particularly striking example. I watched a video of Abdul El-Sayed responding to a young man at a campaign town hall. The man asked whether El-Sayed would disavow the Muslim Brotherhood. El-Sayed answered that he would, then questioned why the man assumed he might not. Was it because he was Muslim? Did his faith somehow make his loyalty to the United States Constitution questionable? The young man acknowledged that he was implying divided loyalties. El-Sayed challenged that assumption directly, speaking about religious freedom and the Constitution’s protection of every American’s right to practice their faith.

What stayed with me was the question beneath the exchange. Why should someone have to prove their loyalty simply because of their religion? I have strong political convictions. There are issues I care deeply about and positions I cannot reconcile with my understanding of compassion, equality, and human dignity. I believe our choices matter, and I don’t think every disagreement can be dismissed as a harmless difference of opinion. But I also believe we lose something important when we stop seeing individuals and begin seeing only categories. We take one piece of information and use it to write an entire story about someone we may never have met.

One of the principles I’ve returned to throughout my years of studying and teaching yoga is ahimsa, often translated as non-harming. I’ve always appreciated how much meaning lives inside such a simple idea. Harm doesn’t begin and end with physical actions. Our words, expressions, assumptions, and reactions can affect people in ways we may never see. Adam and I have said something to our girls for years: “Words cut. Words cut.” A careless comment can stay with someone for decades. A joke repeated often enough can become something a person believes about themselves. A dismissive expression can communicate more than an entire conversation.

My daughter didn’t wake up one morning afraid of becoming a teenager. She learned to associate that word with disappointment through countless little interactions. Most of the people making those comments probably meant no harm. But intention doesn’t erase impact. We have enormous influence over the way people experience themselves in our presence, and I wonder how many wonderful qualities we miss because we’re too busy looking for evidence that our assumptions were right.

Of course, expectations matter. Children need responsibilities. Relationships require accountability. Public officials should be questioned about their decisions. We can hold people to high standards without deciding in advance that they’ll disappoint us. Imagine what might happen if we approached people with genuine curiosity, listened before forming an opinion, noticed the effort behind an imperfect result, and allowed someone to change without continually reminding them who they used to be.

I think about my family this week and recognize that I have some practicing to do myself. My daughters are learning how to contribute when someone needs them. Adam is carrying more than his usual share. And I’m discovering that receiving help requires patience, gratitude, and occasionally letting go of how I think things should be done. None of us has navigated this week perfectly, but we’ve continued showing up for one another. Perhaps that deserves more recognition than the dishes left in the sink.

What strikes me most is that expectations can work in both directions. Words can cut, but they can also encourage. They can give someone the confidence to try something difficult, the courage to speak, or the reassurance that they’re capable of becoming more than they imagined. Imagine telling a teenager how exciting it is to watch her discover herself, approaching an older person with curiosity about everything they’ve experienced, or entering a conversation with someone whose beliefs differ from ours without assuming we already know the answer.

My daughter is thirteen now. She is still the same funny, curious, affectionate, spirited person she was the night before her birthday. Nothing happened at midnight to transform her into the stereotype she’d been warned about. She’s simply beginning another extraordinary chapter of becoming herself. I hope she enters it with excitement and confidence. I hope she questions things, makes mistakes, develops her own beliefs, and discovers strengths she doesn’t yet know she has. Most of all, I hope she understands that she doesn’t have to become the person anyone expects her to be.

Neither do the rest of us. We have opportunities every day to change the way someone experiences the world, often through something as small as a sentence, an expression, or the willingness to listen. Perhaps the next time we’re tempted to roll our eyes, make a familiar joke, or assume we know what someone is thinking, we could consider what we’re adding to that person’s story. Because long after we’ve forgotten what we said, someone else may still be carrying our words. And wouldn’t it be wonderful if the words they carried helped them believe in themselves a little more?