Do We Need to Be Needed?

Gwyneth Paltrow recently described herself as a recovering codependent. Brooke Shields has spoken about aging in a world that once placed enormous value on her beauty. Seth Rogen and his wife, Lauren Miller Rogen, have raised awareness about Alzheimer’s disease, while William Shatner, at 95, has reflected on mortality. Four very different conversations, yet something about them keeps tugging at me: attachment.

I’ve spent much of my adult life studying, practicing, and teaching yoga philosophy, including nonattachment. And after all these years, I’ve come to one rather humbling conclusion: I am spectacularly attached. Not necessarily to possessions, although I’m sure I could find a few things in my house that would prove otherwise. I’m talking about our attachment to the way people, our animals, relationships, accomplishments, and identities make us feel about ourselves.

We become attached to being admired, attractive, successful, respected, loved, or needed. Somewhere along the way, those feelings become intertwined with our understanding of who we are. And then life, which has absolutely no intention of consulting us about its plans, changes something.

In yoga philosophy, aparigraha invites us to examine what we’re holding on to. Nonattachment doesn’t mean withholding love, abandoning ambition, or becoming indifferent to everything that makes life meaningful. It asks us to notice when our happiness and sense of worth depend on something outside ourselves remaining exactly as it is. I understand this intellectually. I can explain it beautifully. Living it? Well, that’s another story.

Years ago, I founded and built a nonprofit organization. The work was deeply meaningful, and I was enormously proud of what we were accomplishing. But can I confess something? My ego absolutely loved it. There was something intoxicating about being the woman who had founded a 501(c)(3). People admired the work, the commitment, the selflessness. I enjoyed the recognition, the community standing, and, if I’m being completely truthful, the almost saintly image that came with it. The work was sincere, but so was the satisfaction I received from being associated with it.

Eventually, I wanted something different. I wanted to stay home and raise my children. When I stepped away from that identity, the recognition I’d once enjoyed no longer seemed particularly important. How enlightened of me, right? Oh, please. I simply traded one attachment for another.

I became a stay-at-home mother and devoted absolutely everything to my three daughters. My days, my energy, my priorities, my heart. I loved our hikes and walks, playing in the mud and letting them get as dirty as they possibly could. I loved losing track of time watching them dance, draw, run, play, and simply be free. There was something magical about those ordinary days and the beautiful chaos of having three children who needed me for practically everything. I wouldn’t change a thing. But here’s where my years of teaching nonattachment become almost comical: I am terrified of the empty nest.

I tell people that the day my demons come knocking will be the day my children begin leaving for college. I can practically hear the footsteps approaching. My girls are my life, my soul, my world. They are my everything, and I mean every word. But I also recognize the enormous attachment wrapped around those words. I went from being the woman who ran a nonprofit to the mother who was needed by three little girls. Different roles, different rewards, but the same underlying reassurance: I matter. I’m important. I’m needed. And being needed feels an awful lot like being loved.

Now those little girls are becoming young women. They have opinions, friendships, interests, and increasingly private worlds of their own. The little girls who once needed me to clean and bandage every scraped knee can now navigate situations without asking my advice. Which is wonderful, except that some small, entirely unreasonable part of me would appreciate being consulted anyway. We spend years teaching our children independence, then they begin doing exactly what we’ve taught them, and suddenly we’re wondering where we fit. Can we love someone without needing them to need us?

I wonder how often this same struggle appears elsewhere. In marriage, we can become attached to being the provider, the caretaker, the decision-maker, or the person who keeps everyone happy. When a spouse changes or grows beyond an old dynamic, we may experience that change as a threat to our importance. Friendships can be equally complicated. Sometimes we hold on because of shared history, the comfort of belonging, or the person we remember being together. Letting a friendship change can feel like surrendering a piece of ourselves.

And careers? Goodness. How many people remain in jobs that no longer fulfill them because of the security, prestige, or status those positions provide? Of course, mortgages need paying and families need feeding. Financial responsibilities are real. But underneath those practical considerations, another question can lurk: Who am I without the title, the salary, or the respect that comes with my work? Retirement can expose that question overnight. After decades of being known for what you do, who are you when you stop doing it?

Even our parents become part of the identities we build. We grow accustomed to them being strong, capable, familiar, and seemingly permanent. Then they begin aging, and we find ourselves grieving changes in people who are still very much here. Alzheimer’s brings an especially painful dimension: someone we love may lose memories of our shared life, changing the familiar ways we feel recognized and known. Their worth remains, even as the relationship changes in ways neither person chose. And mortality reminds us that nothing we cherish was ever promised to remain unchanged.

The unsettling thing is that none of this should surprise us. We know our children will grow up, our bodies will age, relationships will evolve, careers will end, and life itself is temporary. Yet we spend an extraordinary amount of energy trying to preserve what we know cannot stay the same. We don’t always notice how tightly we’re holding on until something begins slipping through our fingers.

This is what makes nonattachment such a profound practice. It challenges us to look beneath what we’re afraid of losing and ask what that loss would mean about us. When beauty fades, do we feel less worthy of being desired? When our children become independent, do we feel less important? When a relationship ends, do we question whether we were lovable? When a career disappears, does our purpose disappear with it? Sometimes we’re afraid of losing more than the thing itself. We’re afraid of losing the person we believe we are because of it.

I don’t want to love my children less, care less about my work, or protect myself from the ache of change. I want to love fiercely, cherish my relationships, and feel the extraordinary privilege of being alive. But I also want to learn how to let those things change without believing that their changing diminishes me. I want my daughters to build lives so full and wonderful that they don’t need me to manage them. Will I cry when they leave? Are you kidding? I’ll be a complete disaster. Still, I hope I can allow myself that grief without asking them to remain little so I can continue feeling needed.

Nonattachment, as I’m coming to understand it, isn’t about becoming untouchable. It’s about allowing life to change without handing every change the power to decide our worth. The people we love were never ours to keep unchanged. Neither were our bodies, careers, reputations, or the identities we’ve spent years constructing. We get to experience them, cherish them, grow through them, and sometimes watch them become something entirely different. And when they do, I wonder what we’re really grieving: what we’ve lost, or who we thought we had to be?